I don’t know how to say this any other way but by being completely honest.
Prom night was amazing, our first kiss… it was so perfect.
I’ll always see you as my better half. You always knew what to say and just what to do. Your mom and your sister can’t stand me. That’s why we aren’t together, you know that. It just really hurts me that you can’t choose us both.
That’s why I had to end it with you.
I love you so much that I couldn’t be selfish and make you choose between me or a good relationship with your family. I don’t know what I could have done to make them dislike me so much, but I tried as hard and took as much as I could take. I will always love you and wonder about what things could have been like.